Financial Times (December 9)
“The Big Four accounting firms have recorded their strongest financial performance since the collapse of Enron as corporate clients rushed to transform their businesses during the coronavirus pandemic.” Revenues soared to over $167 billion, collectively, in spite of “continued criticism of the structure and performance of the firms, especially in audits, including scrutiny of EY’s failure to identify fraud at Wirecard.”
Tags: Accounting firms, Audits, Big Four, Clients, Collapse, Coronavirus, Criticism, Enron, EY, Failure, Financial performance, Fraud, Pandemic, Revenues, Scrutiny, Transform
Financial Times (May 10)
The auditing sector is undergoing a “pitch battle” with new EU regulations that require companies at least tender their audits every 10 years and change auditors every 20 years. “So far the result has been a merry-go-round of audits swapping between the Big Four—PwC, Deloitte, EY and KPMG—which handle 98 per cent of FTSE 350 audits and 95 per cent of those for Fortune 500 companies.”
Tags: Auditors, Audits, Big Four, Deloitte, EU, EY, Fortune 500, FTSE 350, KPMG, PwC, Regulations, Tenders
Bloomberg (October 14)
“Ernst & Young LLP took Bernie Madoff at his word when it signed off on audits of a fund that helped feed the biggest Ponzi scheme in U.S. history. The firm must now defend that decision at the first trial of an auditor over losses tied to Madoff, who’s serving a 150-year prison term for stealing billions of dollars from thousands of investors.” The case will be tried by jury in a state court in Seattle and comes just after “the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, the lead U.S. audit regulator, warns that one in three audit opinions in the U.S. lack appropriate supporting evidence.”
Tags: Audits, Bernie Madoff, Ernst & Young, Evidence, Investors, PCAOB, Ponzi scheme, Prison, Regulator, Seattle, Trial, U.S.
Financial Times (August 19)
Auditors bear some blame for the financial crisis, yet little has been done to improve the quality of their audits. The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) has now proposed more detailed disclosure to highlight items of concern, even when a company passes the audit. “The Securities and Exchange Commission, which has the final say, should adopt the PCAOB’s proposal. This would match similar rules passed by the UK’s Financial Reporting Council…. Pass-fail cannot distinguish accounts that pass with flying colours and those that barely scrape by. Investors deserve better – and investors are auditors’ true constituency even if managers are their employers.”
Tags: Auditors, Audits, Disclosure, Financial Crisis, Financial Reporting Council, Investors, Pass-fail, PCAOB, Quality, Rules, SEC, UK
Financial Times (July 29)
Regulators need to achieve “a complete redesign of audits and the way auditors deliver them.” Currently, auditors provide questionable value. “Did auditors give shareholders any advance warnings about failures and losses at Royal Bank of Scotland, Northern Rock, Anglo Irish, MF Global, Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, AIG or Barclays? US companies spend nearly $50bn annually on the ‘Big Four’ (PwC, Ernst & Young, Deloitte and KPMG) but the auditor rarely speaks or is questioned at annual meetings.”
Regulators need to achieve “a complete redesign of audits and the way auditors deliver them.” Currently, auditors provide questionable value. “Did auditors give shareholders any advance warnings about failures and losses at Royal Bank of Scotland, Northern Rock, Anglo Irish, MF Global, Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, AIG or Barclays? US companies spend nearly $50bn annually on the ‘Big Four’ (PwC, Ernst & Young, Deloitte and KPMG) but the auditor rarely speaks or is questioned at annual meetings.”
Tags: Audits, Big Four, Deloitte, Ernst & Young, KPMG, PwC, Regulators, Shareholders
Financial Times (September 26)
“The business model of the Big Four accounting firms is under attack from the European Commission, which is pushing for tough rules that would force the firms to abandon their consultancy businesses and share audit work with smaller rivals.” The draft legislation is hardly a sure thing and the Big Four will likely do all they can to fight it, but Michel Barnier, the EUs internal market commissioner, is supporting the legislation as way to restore confidence in financial reporting.
Tags: Accounting, Audits, Big Four, EU, Financial reporting
